I think I've figured it out what has gone awry at American Idol.
First of all, I don't think Antonella should still be involved in this competition. She did the same thing that Frenchy did years ago and they kicked Frenchy off for it. But, I think that they actually were worried because of the following differences between the two:
A.) Frenchy could actually sing and had a shot at winning the top Idol spot. Antonella can't sing a note and they know her days are numbered anyway
B.) Antonella is a hot white girl that is easy on the eyes. Frenchy wasn't as typically All American as Antonella and we all know this is as much a beauty competition as a singing one.
C.) Antonella actually thought her photos would lead her to her audition on American Pole Dancer - she just showed up at the wrong hotel. Frenchy showed up to actually audition for American Idol.
They both did the same thing, however Frenchy had to leave and Antonella gets to stay. I think this is a real shame for all of the contestants on American Idol - and especially all of the contestants that were kicked off over the years due to one thing or another that weren't any worse than Antonella's audition photos for Girls Gone Wild.
Well, hopefully this week the voters will actually hear the fact that the girl sounds like she's the third place contestant at the Karaoke bar instead of an actual singer. But, that won't happen since, obviously, more than half of all Americans are totally tone deaf. How else can we explain Britney Spears and Sanjaya?